Inheriting a house can be a huge major headache, especially when a sibling refuses to leave the inherited house. Whether it's a brother who lives in the inherited house or a sister living rent free in the inherited house, navigating family dynamics, legal rights, and financial responsibilities can get complicated fast.
If you're facing this emotionally and legally tricky situation, you're not alone. Here's what you need to know, your options, and how to move forward without burning bridges.
Why a Sibling Might Stay in the House
It’s more common than you might think for a sibling living in the deceased parents' house to simply stay put—especially if they were already living there before your parents passed away.
In many cases, the sibling may have acted as a caregiver and now feels entitled to remain in the home. Others may have no other housing options or lack the financial means to move out, making the inherited property their only form of stability.
Sometimes, a sibling genuinely believes they inherited the house alone, either due to a misunderstanding of the will or the absence of a clear estate plan. And in some cases, they may simply refuse to leave out of emotional attachment or stubbornness.
Whatever the reason, it doesn’t change the fact that you may also be a legal heir—entitled to your share of the home or its proceeds.
Understanding Ownership Rights for Inherited Properties
If a house was left equally to multiple siblings, no single person has more legal claim to it than the others. The home becomes a shared asset, and unless the will or trust says otherwise, each sibling typically owns an equal portion. That shared ownership has serious implications—especially when one sibling is living in the house while the others are not.
Here’s what this usually means:
All decisions must be made jointly. No one can sell, rent, renovate, or refinance the home without agreement from all co-owners.
One sibling can’t take over the home alone. Even if they’ve lived there for years, they don’t gain special ownership unless it was explicitly stated in the will.
Living rent-free may not be fair. The sibling occupying the home could owe “occupancy rent” or need to reimburse the others for their share of the property's value.
Disagreements may require legal action. A partition lawsuit can force the sale or division of the home if no agreement is reached.
Financial contributions matter. If one sibling paid for repairs, taxes, or the mortgage, the court may factor that in during any settlement or sale.
These issues can escalate quickly, especially when emotions are still raw. That’s why it’s helpful to understand the basics of inheriting a house with siblings, especially how to avoid conflict and create clear agreements.
What to Do if a Sibling Refuses to Leave the Inherited Property
It’s frustrating when a sibling digs in their heels—especially after you’ve tried to have honest, respectful conversations about the future of the inherited home. Maybe they’re emotionally attached to the house, maybe they’re struggling financially, or maybe they just don’t want to face reality. Whatever the reason, if your sibling refuses to leave the inherited house or won’t agree on what to do with it, you may feel stuck with no good options.
The good news? You do have legal and financial paths forward—even if things feel tense. Whether your goal is to keep the peace, get your fair share, or simply move on, here are the next steps to consider when informal talks have broken down.
1. Request Rent or a Buyout from Your Sibling Staying at the Inherited Home
If your sibling wants to stay in the home, one of the most practical and peaceful solutions is to ask them to either start paying rent or buy out your share of the property.
Requesting rent: You can propose that they pay fair market rent based on current rates in the area. This ensures you're compensated for your ownership interest while allowing them to continue living there.
Proposing a buyout: If they’re emotionally invested in staying and have the financial means, a buyout might make more sense. They would pay you (and any other heirs) your fair share based on the home’s current market value. This allows them to become the sole owner, while you walk away with your portion of the inheritance.
Be sure to document any agreements in writing, and consider involving a real estate attorney to help draft a formal arrangement that protects everyone’s interests.
2. Selling the Inherited House and Splitting Proceeds
When no one wants—or can afford—to keep the home, selling the inherited property and dividing the profits is often the cleanest solution. But things get tricky if your sibling refuses to leave the inherited house or won’t cooperate in the sale.
This kind of stalemate is where a partition action comes in. It’s a legal process that allows any co-owner to ask the court to force the sale of jointly owned property. If approved, a judge can order the home to be sold (either at auction or on the open market) and ensure all rightful heirs receive their portion of the proceeds.
While a partition action can be time-consuming and emotionally draining, it may be the only way to resolve the issue if negotiations fail. It’s best to consult a probate or real estate attorney early to understand your options and increase the chances of a smoother outcome.
How to Evict a Brother From an Inherited Property
Here's the part that gets uncomfortable. Evicting a sibling from an inherited home is never easy—emotionally or legally. You both have just lost a loved one and now you're at each other's necks. Probably the last thing you want to do is to learn how to evict a brother (or sister) from an inherited property.
But if you've exhausted all other options and they're refusing to leave or cooperate, you may have no choice but to take legal action. Whether they’re living rent-free, preventing a sale, or simply overstaying their welcome, it’s important to approach the situation carefully and within the law.
Here’s a general process if you're wondering how to evict a brother from inherited property or a sister who won't leave:
STEP 1: Clarify Ownership Rights
Before beginning the eviction process, confirm you’re a legal co-owner or sole heir. If the property is still under the estate’s name, you’ll likely need to complete probate or be appointed as executor to act on behalf of the estate.
If the home is already in your name or shared with siblings, and one refuses to leave, you may have legal standing to act.
STEP 2: Serve Formal Notice to Vacate
Serve your sibling with a written notice to quit—a document that gives them a set time (e.g., 30–90 days) to move out. Even if they aren’t paying rent, the law often still requires notice, depending on your state.
STEP 3: File an Unlawful Detainer Lawsuit
If they still won’t leave, you’ll need to file an eviction lawsuit in probate or civil court. Be prepared to show:
Proof of ownership
Probate filings (if applicable)
Copies of notice served
The court will consider who owns the home and whether your sibling has a legal right to stay.
STEP 4: Attend the Court Hearing
Both parties will present their cases. Judges often encourage mediation, but if no agreement is reached, the court may issue a judgment of possession in your favor.
STEP 5: Request a Sheriff-Led Eviction
Once granted, you can request a sheriff’s eviction. Law enforcement will post a final notice and remove your sibling if they haven’t vacated by the deadline.
Evicting a sister living rent free in an inherited house or a brother refusing to move isn’t easy, and it’s rarely fast. But courts do step in when co-heirs can’t agree—and if all negotiations fail, this may be the only way forward.
Final Thoughts
A sibling refusing to leave an inherited house can quickly turn into a family feud—but it doesn’t have to. Understanding your rights and seeking the right legal support can help you resolve the issue fairly. Whether your goal is to keep the house, sell it, or just get closure, know that there are solutions available.
Want to understand all your options before making a move? Start with our complete guide to inheriting a house—and don’t hesitate to reach out if you need help selling an inherited property quickly and fairly.
Learn More About Us!
Come visit us in our About Us page to learn more about your local homebuying couple!
Learn more what our company is all about, we can't wait to chat with you soon 🙂
The Best Way To Sell Your House Fast
Are you looking to sell your house? Our friendly team at 702 Cash Buyers is here to help you through every step of the process. We buy houses in Las Vegas Nevada. Join our community of satisfied sellers who have successfully sold their houses to us. Let's work together to make your property selling experience easy and stress-free. Click on the button below to get started!